I Tried Thinx Period Panties- Play by Play Review

thinxfeatured

I’m not afraid to discuss all things period.  In fact, I do it all the time when I host my session at MommyCon!  I stand in front of a decently large crowd and show people how menstrual cups work while wearing uterus leggings (to scale) for educational purposes.  It was only natural that when a company came out guns a blazing with period panties– advertised to take the place of menstrual products completely- people were like “KIM!  WHAT’S THE DEAL WITH THINX?”

Like the menstrual cup, I wasn’t running towards Thinx period panties.  I referred to them in private convos as the “blood diaper and as a former tampon/current menstrual cup user they didn’t appeal to me AT.  ALL.

A photo posted by Kim Rosas (@kim_rosas) on

I finally ordered a pair because curiosity got the best of me and I wanted to form my own opinion for future questions about them.  My underwear, after using a $10 off referral code, cost a whopping $28.  I went with the high waist since these are great for under leggings for those of us with junk in the front.  If you’re good with thongs you can pay $24 ($14 with a $10 off coupon) but these have less absorbency. For your viewing pleasure I photographed my “granny panties” for the world to see.  #noshame.  There are other, much less expensive options available on Amazon including this highly rated pair from Anigan.  Even with $10 off you won’t be getting Thinx for a steal.

thinx underwear hanging to dry

According to Thinx their panties can be worn as a backup to other products or used alone.  Considering they have the amount of liquid each holds (the style I chose holds 1 1/2 tampon’s worth) on their website and packaging I decided to go all in and try it without other protection.  Here is a timeline of my day and how it went.  I wrote brief notes during the day and have pasted them here.

11:40 Finally showered, cup out, put on Thinx.  Day 2 of cycle and my heaviest day.

1:43 Bathroom and wiped- no residue on top layer but 3+ wipes to get all blood off.  Wishing I had a bidet.

2:30 Couch time. Can’t feel anything wet but have that sensation of stuff leaving my vag.  Praying not to bleed on my re-upholstered vintage couch.  

3:00 Bathroom.  Something on top layer- mucous blood clots about a nickel in size, dark around that where fluid was trapped inside, lots of blood each wipe for 3 wipes.  Pulled panties back on and they felt damp/cold but after a minute not noticed due to body heat.

5:10 Done. A good bit of mucous on top layer, quarter size. No leaks but could tell it was more than time.  Took off Thinx and went with a cloth liner plus handy cup.  

I made sure to take a photo wearing Thinx under leggings. Obligatory dirty mirror for realness

I had predicted on Facebook that I could wear a Thinx 5-6 hours based on their chart and my average Day 2 flow.  I was pretty spot on with my timing since I wore them for 5.5 hours!  #patsback I should have put some money on it!

I’ll admit that the panties were shockingly effective.  The high waist model were true to size and very comfortable- I actually washed them and wore them again as back-up with my cup for my last day.  I’ve worn the period panties from Lunapads and Thinx were much more breathable and they look like regular underwear which I love.  Not only do they look like regular underwear, but they are so trim that even hanging to dry no one would guess there were absorbent layers in the crotch. (Thinx should be cared for like cloth diapers in some ways… rinse after wear, cold wash, hang to dry and no fabric softeners.  You can still wash with regular clothing but storing in a reusable small wet bag would be ideal until wash day.)

Odor.  I almost forgot this part.  I did periodical sniff tests (fairly close to the underwear I might add…) and for my 5 hours even at the last hour there were no foul odors or anything that screamed I had been wearing undies soaked with menstrual blood for the day.  On the full day it was worn as backup it was the same story, though to be honest they probably had no menstrual blood because my cup and I are besties and it’s almost 100% effective with the exception of a few “wiping leaks.”

Thinx Underwear trimness example

The obvious drawback of Thinx (and pads of any kind) is that they won’t absorb the mucousy portion of menstrual flow, so it just kind of sits there until you go to the bathroom.  This is why menstrual cups will ALWAYS be my #1 choice for my period.  I’m not a pads person and they don’t have the comfort or convenience of cups.  The Thinx panties were effective as long, even longer, than if I were wearing a regular cloth pad so color me impressed.

Thinx are well suited for back-up, absolutely.  They feel no different than underwear while being worn so if needed or not it’s not a burden to wear them.  They would also be great for those spotty days (or for those who just have very light, spotty periods) when it’s not enough to wear a cup but too much to go without a liner.  Overnights?  Excellent.  Wear as insurance for your sheets.  I have worn thin cloth liners on occasion and plan to replace the day or two I wear those with a pair of Thinx since they’re so much trimmer and wear the same as regular underwear.  The idea that these would work full time is not ideal- changing a pair of underwear 5 hours into your day just won’t work.  If they’re only being used for backup then they can last the full day or perhaps the full day on very light days.  Their website is quite helpful in understanding how these work.

Here’s the tough part.  The price.  GULPS.  If you had told me in college that I would pay $28 for a pair of panties I wouldn’t have believed you.  It wasn’t even close to being in my budget.  Even now it’s not a price I want to pay but I see the benefits of the product enough that having 1-2 is a good thing.  A full set for a cycle?  I would need a big traffic increase on this blog to be willing and able to throw that down for panties.  They have a “buy one give one” model where for each pair of Thinx sold they donate to Afripads.

Packaging: After my first order for the review pair of Thinx I made several sales, enough to order another style to try.  My 2nd order with 2 pair of Thinx came in another style of packaging, one far less discreet.  While I don’t mind I’m sure others do.  If you mind, I suggest another brand such as Lunapanties or Anigan, both sold on Amazon that would ship in plain packaging without tampons or a uterus on it.

Thinx has devised a brilliant way of marketing their products that lets you refer people so if you want to buy Thinx and want more than 1 pair but just can’t right now you can spam your friends until they buy a pair and save $10 which gives you $10 in credits.  You can start with my code to save $10 on a pair and if I make sudden “THINX millions” after this goes live maybe I can order up a few for a giveaway.  I had been in discussions with a PR rep from Thinx to do a post and giveaway, we even had a phone call, but they never followed through with their plans.  For that reason I ordered my own but it’s been frustrating that my plans for an earlier review and giveaway were dashed.  Despite that frustrating experience the product is a good one and worth sharing.  

UPDATE to original post: After posting this review and selling over 500+ (at least) pairs of Thinx the company has changed their referral program.  Prior to this I was rolling in $10 Thinx gift codes that I used for giveaways and I gave them to friends who wanted to try Thinx.  I was the gosh-darn panty fairy.  I emailed Thinx when the codes really started raining because, really, how many panties can one girl use?  Not a few thousand dollars worth I assure you.  I inquired about the possibility of working with them on a buy-back program of codes (at a far reduced rate, not 1 to 1 ratio) since panties can’t pay the bills, ya’ll.  It was (and is) a tight time around here since I dumped my advertising network and large, home related expenses keep popping up, as they tend to do in groups.  I asked Thinx if they had considered a real affiliate network for those of us with larger audiences who would rather make a small % of sales versus money towards panties.  The reply was that they were actually discontinuing their program, and they didn’t elaborate.  $10 codes continued to roll in, upwards of 20+ a day at times.  Then, the emails changed from $10 in “blood money” to $10 off a single purchase of Thinx.”  I don’t know about you, but the chances of me making over 100 individual orders of panties are pretty darn slim.  This was even WORSE than panty money, and utterly useless.  As an added slap in the face the remaining 140+ $10 gift codes were suddenly completely disabled with no warning.  YES.  All that panty money I was rolling in vanished.  I EARNED that panty money (I recognize how silly that sounds).    I emailed Thinx once again, and asked why the codes had been disabled with no warning and for them to reactivate them. After all, I sold bajillions of panties for them.  Those codes, part of their program as they designed it, were earned and belonged to me.  After a bit of back and forth with a rep from Thinx replies stopped coming.

Thinxcodes

Now this post is on the front page of Google for Thinx reviews.  My website IS my job, every post I do adds to the money pool of how I pay for my son’s Pre-K, how I pay the credit card bills, how I buy groceries and help provide my family with the things we need.  I’m selling a ton of panties thanks to the hard-earned SEO that 7+ years of blogging has earned me.

My positive review of Thinx still stands of course, the panties work great.  You are certainly encouraged to use them if that’s what you want, but I did want to give some feedback on my experience with the COMPANY.   There are other options that are much less expensive.  Thinx didn’t invent the period panty, they just made it more visible with their advertising and marketing plan (that I have been part of by having a popular post, not by design, but as it happens.)

Written By
More from Kim Rosas

Fluffy Mama of the Week- Pamela

Meet our Fluffy Mama of the Week, Pamela.  Here is a little...
Read More
  • Shelia

    I looked into these, although my periods are extremely light after having a procedure done called Novasure. I’m not here to push this proceduremail but I highly recommend it if you are having heavy periods and do not want to have anymore children. I’m 43 and have always had HEAVY periods, quarter sized clots and gushing blood when I stood up. I couldn’t go anywhere, including work, on the 2nd or 3rd day of my period. Also have your hormones and thyroid checked. Novasure has been a miracle for me. I have spotty periods for about 3 or 4 days and I’m done. Panty liner is more than plenty for me now!

  • CYG

    Just wanted to say thank you for your very candid review. I appreciate the honesty which helps others such as myself can relate to in “real world” situations. As many of the other commenters have stated I am too unhappy of the way that this company has treated you and maybe others bloggers who are reviewing their product. For a company who states they are helping girls in other countries with their menstrual problems but can act a certain way to people who help promote their product tells a lot about the characteristics of that company or at least the “Rep” of that company. If the owner CEO doesn’t know of this she needs to be made aware of it and if she does know of this then she needs to get off her self appointed high horse.

  • Meg

    Thank you for your honest and hilarious review, especially with alternatives!!!

  • CountSudooku

    I don’t get why people are like, “well if it only works for five hours then blah blah blah you can’t use it.”

    If you can’t be home to change them then you wear them as backup to a tampon or something else while you’re at work. On my heaviest couple of days I still need to use a tampon, but I don’t need to panic if I can’t change it as quickly as I should. That’s where Thinx come in. NO LEAKS!

    At night especially they’re unbeatable.

    The hiphuggers are SO COMFY.

  • Kat

    Just wanted to say I had been considering getting this & was looking up reviews first, but the company’s dishonesty in dealing with your referrals has made me decide not to buy from them. I don’t think it’s technically a contract but that’s very bad faith & not a good look for a brand.

  • Holly

    Thanks for the great review, I’m so excited to give these a go, they may not be perfect, but how great is it to see companies out there challenging the status quo for women?
    Here’s a code for $10 off if anyones keen to give them a try, but baulking at the price!
    http://fbuy.me/eE1aK

  • Joy

    +1 had thinx in my cart before I saw this review, and decided to try an alternative instead because I do not want to support a dishonest company. 🙂

  • April

    What a disappointing company experience. I recently tried another amazon brand you listed, Anigan, and found myself content, but open to information on other brands. I’ll continue to suggest my own experience and forward your review on to individuals.
    Panty pimps gotta get paid! With such a personal item, dishing out the money without hearing about another’s experience usually is a no go. They are lucky to have your review up.

  • Melissa Howell

    Thanks for the share. Your experience with the company is my decision makers. Poor customer service = no customer.

  • Julie Brown

    Grrr…. 😡 you went to them honest, not even for a 1:1 ratio, and they did this!? Could of started your own thing to take preorders as some sort of retailer to cash in! Companies seek out people with followings to do reviews, WHY do this to YOU!???! Change your policy, but don’t con someone out of the perks they accrued. BAD BUSINESS! If they make things right, I’d be willing to give them another chance, though as it stands I will NOT give any business to a company like this.

    • Julie Brown

      If you start a petition, it would be nice to know. I’ll sign and support you.

  • Adelon D

    PLEASE LEARN HOW TO USE COMMAS

  • Emily

    Thank you for your honest review. I came here ready to buy THInX, but now I am going to buy the cheaper version due to your horrible experience with them. As someone who has worked in affiliate marketing for a few years, I couldn’t in good conscience buy from a company who treats their partners so poorly. Good for you for your honesty and unbiased opinion!